What Shapes Green Industrial Policy Objectives and Design? A Comparative Policy Analysis of Renewable Energy Auctions in India and South Africa

Abstract

The article compares the renewable energy auctions of India and South Africa, two countries with different institutional approaches to governing markets and different political-economic constraints, to understand how these factors shaped similar policy objectives to be prioritised differently through their auction design. It finds that India’s market-based governance approach and its electricity sector politics resulted in the prioritisation of electricity price objectives while South Africa’s developmental state approach prioritised industry localisation and employment creation objectives through policy design. The survival of India’s politics-centered approach over South Africa’s problem-centered policy design has implications for countries implementing multiple-objective policies.